Stephen Hebscher successfully argues for exclusion of evidence, resulting in a judge acquitting a Toronto man of carrying a concealed weapon!
A judge has acquitted a Toronto man of carrying a concealed weapon — a BB gun — because police were unable to specify what offence they suspected him of committing before searching him.
“No less than four Charter rights were breached in one brief encounter with a young black man … who was simply standing outside a strip mall,” Ontario Court Justice Diane Oleskiw wrote in a 17-page ruling released this week.
The multiple violations include arbitrary detention, failure to advise him of the reason for his detention, right to counsel and conducting an unauthorized search.
The encounter began shortly before midnight on April 26, 2011, when two officers in a marked cruiser spotted Jovel Stewart, 22, and two others “huddled” in a dark alcove in a plaza in a high-crime area near Keele St. and Lawrence Ave. W.
Constables Rick White and Mark Luchetta “felt the need” to speak to the trio because of where they were standing and the fact they were wearing dark, heavy coats and hoods on a warm spring night, the judge wrote.
The officers approached Stewart — his companions ran off — and found him “nervous” and unresponsive to their questions, though he provided his correct name and address and removed his hand from his jacket when told to.
After White determined Stewart had an outstanding fraud charge, the officer conducted a pat-down search “for officer safety” and found an air cartridge ball-bearing gun beneath his clothing.
But the judge agreed with defence lawyer Stephen Hebscher that the way the evidence was obtained was the result of multiple Charter breaches by the officers.
Weapons Charges Dismissed
“Throughout the entire interaction with Mr. Stewart, they were suspicious of some kind of criminal activity, but they could not say what kind of criminal activity or that the suspicion was directed at any particular offence.”
Oleskiw also noted that “people of different ethnicities sometimes dress in heavy clothing during warm weather, and young black males are sometimes nervous around police officers.”
Admitting the BB-gun into evidence obtained “as a result of multiple breaches that have a serious effect on the constitutional rights of individuals sends the message that these breaches are condoned by the court,” she wrote.
She added that while a BB-gun is “certainly not a toy and is capable of causing real harm, it is not a firearm.” Nor was there a suggestion it was loaded.
“This case is just another example of police targeting certain visible minorities for ‘investigation’ based upon discriminatory criteria,” Hebscher wrote in email.
This article was originally posted here in The Toronto Star on Wednesday August 01, 2012 by Betsy Powell.
I came to Stephen Hebscher with a somewhat irregular case. Both my spouse and I had been mutually charged with domestic assault, a legal situation that neither of us had wished upon each other. While my spouse's lawyer had been content to seek mutually binding peace bonds, Stephen was able to get in front of the case and negotiate a withdrawal of both of our charges- the best possible outcome on BOTH sides of the table – once we successfully completing the PARs program. I remain entirely pleased with Stephen's competency, professionalism and accessibility, and would not hesitate to recommend him as a criminal defence lawyer. L.A.
Mr. Hebscher: I would like to thank you for your excellent representation of me in relation to the domestic assault charges that you worked so hard to have withdrawn. You have made a critical difference in my future and I am very happy with the outcome. I also appreciate your hard work, and the extra time and effort you have put in to deal with all the other issues that came along. I thank you for being a phone call away (or email) even when you did not have to be. I will gladly recommend your services to any of my friends or family should they ever need it. I am very grateful for what you have done.
I am impressed especially after our meeting on Monday – I was resigned that something bad would befall me, so I am very blessed to have this outcome. I thank you for the hard work that you have put into this case, and the dedication on getting me this fantastic outcome! I am so glad that we retained you as my lawyer! You have done an outstanding job and allowed me to now rebuild my life. Thank you, Bruce Karten.
Dave B. (Ajax, Ontario)
We were referred to Stephen Hebscher when our child was in need of legal representation. He was charged with sexual assault. As parents, we were quite frightened for our child but Mr. Hebscher was the calm voice of reason. We are very grateful to Mr. Hebscher for the excellent results he got for our child, as the charges were dropped.
J.N. (Toronto, Ontario)
Mr. Hebscher is a very professional lawyer who takes pride in his work and because of this the end result was the judge ruling me not guilty and I got my innocence and life back. My family and I would like to thank you again Stephen Hebscher for doing a wonderful job and also being a very supportive man.
Chris T. (Scarborough, Ontario)
I am happy to report that Bruce’s superior negotiation strategy and ability to present facts effectively helped convince the Crown to reduce his position. I would like to take this opportunity to thank Bruce for getting my charge withdrawn and keep my criminal record clean.
J.S (Toronto, Ontario)
I looked and found Barrister Stephen Hebscher I introduced myself and my case and after listening to all details he was able to ensure me that my case would go well. All charges against me have be thrown out and my life is back to normal.
Blair H. (North York)
Bruce ...The care and concern you showed us during our dealings certainly helped to reduce the stress we were under. I would recommend you without a second thought. Your winning record is a bonus as well. My husband and myself can't thank you enough for all you've done for our family.
Debi T. (Mississauga, Ontario)
Dear Mr. Hebscher...There are not enough words to express my appreciation for your...giving me your undivided attention at all times, work in my case with your heart and soul, that makes you "ONE OF A KIND" lawyer.
Ahmed A. (Brampton, Ontario)
Mr. Bruce Karten was able to help to extricate me from a very serious criminal case containing severe charges, including weapons –threat to use weapons, death threat, harassment,etc. He succeeded in winning my case. I was discharged; was able to keep my career, and no criminal record. This was a tremendous accomplishment, and I am very appreciative of that.
Nickolai V. (Toronto, Ontario)
Again, from the depth of our hearts we sincerely thank you very much for being my Counsel on this case. We now can say you are the BEST and we will surely recommend you to our friends and anybody here we know who needs the best Lawyer in Ontario. You have done an extremely good job and we are very happy with the outcome this morning.
Roman A. (Markham, Ontario)
Mr. Hebscher was the only lawyer who gave me hope and made me feel like I had a real fighting chance. I am extremely satisfied with the quick results that he delivered, and I am happy to say that he was able to convince the court to drop the charges against me and clear my name.
Tina M. (Toronto, Ontario)